Skip to episode

Episode 11

Kristin Neff: Self-Compassion and Non-dual Awareness

Listen to the conversation

Open on Transistor

Introduction

Kristin Neff was my professor at UT Austin. In this conversation, we pick up a discussion about what she has been discovering through nondual meditation and how it connects with self-compassion.

We compare experiences from retreats with Michael Taft and Dustin DiPerna, including the relationship between understanding a view and learning to sustain it in practice. Kristin describes her attempt to build a model of awareness and consciousness that makes sense of her experience. She is explicit about its limits: compatibility with science is different from scientific proof.

The conversation then returns to a familiar difficulty: understanding an idea does not necessarily stop us from judging ourselves. We explore the protective intentions behind shame and the inner critic, and how kindness can coexist with the firmness needed to act.

In this conversation

  • 00:00 — Nondual retreats, concepts, and practice. Comparing retreat experiences and the role of concepts in understanding practice.
  • 06:20 — Awake awareness, mind-wandering, and creativity. Exploring the relationship between awareness and thought.
  • 14:22 — What changed after 50 meditation retreats. Kristin reflects on changes in her own practice.
  • 19:02 — Kristin’s evolving model of nondual awareness. A conceptual account of her experience, with a distinction between scientific compatibility and proof.
  • 35:43 — “You are not your thoughts” and what comes next. Looking beyond a familiar meditation instruction.
  • 54:51 — Self-compassion through a nondual lens. Connecting practice with Kristin’s work on kindness and common humanity.
  • 01:08:27 — The inner critic, shame, and the wish to be loved. Considering the protective intentions behind self-judgment.
  • 01:15:54 — Fierce self-compassion: acceptance and action. Making room for care that includes boundaries and change.
  • 01:20:33 — AI, consciousness, and subjective experience. Exploring questions about intelligence and experience.
  • 01:28:24 — What Kristin is working on now. Where these questions are taking her work.

These timestamps follow the published V1 chapter guide and are approximate.

Transcript

Adapted from the reviewed original-edit transcript and aligned with the timed V1 source. Lightly cleaned for reading; speaker labels and timestamps are approximate. This is not verbatim captions and has not received a full audio proofread. Suggest a correction.

00:00 — Nondual retreats, concepts, and practice

Pranab · 00:00

We're here with Dr. Kristin Neff, who was my professor at UT several years ago, known for mindful self-compassion and her books on fierce compassion and burnout. We were just talking about non-dual retreats, and we're going to get right back into it and keep talking about that.

Kristin Neff · 00:16

It's interesting: in Mahamudra, they often talk about how the concepts actually need to come first, and then the experience.

Pranab · 00:22

That's interesting.

Kristin Neff · 00:23

Whereas I think a lot of people say, “No, it's first the experience, and then we understand it.” But I think that model I made you read—how many times?

Pranab · 00:32

I've got a little skim of it here, just in case.

Kristin Neff · 00:35

The reason it's important to me—not everyone's like me, not everyone thinks like me, but I suspect people like you are like me. There's a certain group of people, especially younger people, who don't want to reject science. They don't want to go woo-woo. They're interested in quantum physics and how the world works. They don't want to have to believe in karma and reincarnation. Maybe it's true, maybe not, but I don't want to have to believe that.

For me, I needed to find a way to conceptualize things that made sense to me, that fit with what I was learning in non-duality, but that wasn't incompatible with science. Is it proven by science? No, of course, but it just has to be compatible. That helped me slot all the pieces in so I wasn't sitting there thinking, “Well, that doesn't make sense. Five sentences ago, you used consciousness one way, and now you're using it in a totally new way.” It bugs people like me. It doesn't bug everyone.

Pranab · 01:36

It bugs me too. Completely agreed. I really loved this during my retreat too: the idea that it's sort of asymptotic. You can never really explain it, but you can always have more and more precise approximations.

Kristin Neff · 01:54

Yeah, exactly.

Pranab · 01:54

And that's really useful. That's awesome.

Kristin Neff · 01:58

So tell me. I love Michael Taft. One of the things I liked about Dustin DiPerna is all the meditations are like ten minutes. There's an emphasis that the meditation is not the thing, so don't get too attached to meditation. I'm curious what happened, because I know Michael likes those long, deep ones.

Pranab · 02:20

For sure. It's really interesting. I've personally been returning to long meditations and almost a more Theravada approach to practice, which for me has been good: the concentration, the states of samadhi. I was aware that Dustin's retreats only had, I think, 20-minute maximum meditations.

Kristin Neff · 02:41

My understanding of it is less—ten minutes.

Pranab · 02:44

Ten minutes? Really? Whoa. And I imagine it's to get really crisp on the view.

Kristin Neff · 02:48

Except for the introductory one.

Pranab · 02:51

You did the intermediate?

Kristin Neff · 02:52

I did the advanced. I skipped the intermediate because it was all about compassion, and he said, “That's probably just going to bug you, the way we're doing it.”

Pranab · 03:01

Probably. Okay, I would love to hear about that. I'll tell you about Michael Taft. His retreat was seven days, really six full days of meditation. There's a lot of meditation. On average, most people got at least four hours. I got about six. If you really wanted to, you could push eight or ten, I think.

There were two Michael Taft sessions per day: a mix of lecture, guided meditation, and Q&A. This one leaned much more toward guided meditation, with lots of practice periods of anywhere from 30 minutes to an hour throughout the day. So lots of sitting time.

The retreat comprised mostly—maybe 70 percent or more—people who had done prior retreats and his courses. Out of the 60-ish people, there were only four who hadn't done any of the courses or anything. So a lot of people came in with Michael experience.

The point of the retreat was, “Cool, you've got some approximation of the view.” He often talks about approximating the view. “Now just practice it and sustain it.” So it was a lot of shamatha. We actually did a lot of tonglen practice, compassion and tonglen. This is my fourth Michael Taft retreat, and a lot of the other ones have a lot of pointing-out, vipassana, and different types of things. So it's kind of a grab bag.

I feel like with Dustin's retreats, you know what you're going to get. It's very much, “This is it. This is this level,” which is really good in a lot of ways.

Kristin Neff · 04:39

It takes you all the way to non-dual awake awareness, the view, at the end of the introductory retreat. Then the advanced is all about stabilizing it. What was really useful was seeing the difference between ordinary awareness and awake awareness, and being able to move back to awake awareness seamlessly, without effort. That's really important.

You don't need to concentrate the mind. At first you do, but after a certain number of times, the brain's got it. It knows it. You just instantly shift. So now I'm catching myself. Right now I'm in the view, but I'm starting to notice when I'm out of the view. The nice thing is, it's not like, “I'm in the view! I'm awake!” It's like, “No, I'm just coming from my basis of operation.”

It's so cute. My brain—this is weird. Maybe it's age. His name is… I can see him. Anyway, it'll come. He calls it “basis of operation,” BOO.

Pranab · 05:52

I've heard of “basis of operation.” I think that phrase sounds familiar.

Kristin Neff · 05:59

That's really annoying. It's right on the tip of my tongue. The nice thing is, I'm not controlling what's arising in the contents of my consciousness. And the unconscious is not doing it. My non-reflective consciousness is not doing its work. Anyway.

06:20 — Awake awareness, mind-wandering, and creativity

Kristin Neff · 06:16

It's just: where are you coming from? Are you coming from the perspective of a separate self, separate from the world? Or are you coming from the perspective of awareness, which is everything? And it's also outside of space and time, always here, always now.

When you do that, you can feel the difference. It's very distinct, because it's almost like lights on or lights off. You notice when the lights have been off, and then, “Oh yeah, I lost it.” But it's not a special thing. Special states come and go, like states of incredible bliss and love and compassion and stillness. You might get in a state of samadhi, very, very quiet. All sorts of stuff can arise, but that's not it.

The reason that's so useful to someone like me is—I have to tell you, I'm also a little bit of a rebel. We were practicing king of samadhi, which is how to be totally in awake awareness as you're very narrowly focused on one thing, that one-pointedness. I created my own practice, and I call it the queen of not paying attention.

Pranab · 07:26

That's awesome.

Kristin Neff · 07:27

Because you need awake awareness when you're spacing out, when you're mind-wandering. For me, mind-wandering is a very creative time. When I'm not paying attention to anything, my mind is going here and there. It's kind of floating. That's the seed of creativity. Of course, neuroscientists are starting to rehabilitate mind-wandering and see it as a huge source of creativity.

So can I maintain awake awareness while I'm mind-wandering? I don't know if this happens to you, but I space out regularly. It's almost like my brain takes a rest. Does that happen to you?

Pranab · 08:03

Yeah. From everything you're saying, I think we have very similar brains that way.

Kristin Neff · 08:06

Not everyone has a brain like this, but I think people who are used to focusing and can really focus—my brain needs periodic rest. It might need that rest every three minutes, and it just goes fuzzy. So I've learned to stay awake while my brain goes fuzzy, because you can stay awake through all of it.

Pranab · 08:25

You can't do samadhi through all of it.

Kristin Neff · 08:27

No. You can't pay attention. So I really got clear on the difference between paying attention, which is really what mindfulness is, and awake awareness, which is different. I used to go on mindfulness retreats and be exhausted trying to pay attention to everything. First of all, there's someone who's doing it, and also you're focusing. Focusing is an action, and you can be awake while you focus.

But it was really amazing. Right now, I'll do it. I'll allow myself to space out. I'm still awake, even though I'm not focusing on you or anything. When I was asking a question, I allowed myself to rehearse. They always say, “Don't rehearse. Pay attention to what's arising.” I really played with, “No, I'm going to see if I can stay awake while I'm not paying attention to what's happening and I'm just rehearsing what I'm going to say.”

Pranab · 09:28

Nothing excluded.

Kristin Neff · 09:29

Nothing excluded. It's all within awareness. All those things really came online for me. I've had those insights before, but it really came together. Because of that, it's much easier for me to stabilize the awakening, because I'm not excluding those moments of mind-wandering or spacing out that my brain needs. Maybe not everyone does.

Pranab · 09:55

Do you identify with ADHD-like stuff?

Kristin Neff · 09:58

No, but I can focus very easily. I don't know. I'm sure there are neuroscientists studying this stuff, but it seems like, especially if you're someone who's creative—and I'm creative, not in an artistic way, but intellectually; I write a lot of stuff—mind-wandering, that half-drifty, dreaming space where you've got half-ideas and it's forming, but you aren't directing it or paying attention, it's just happening—that's a really important time for me.

Some of my absolute best ideas come when I've just woken up, when I'm half-awake in the morning and my mind's wandering. Sometimes I do that in the day as well. It seems like I'm just spacing out or not paying attention. I need that time, because that's when I think most creatively.

Pranab · 10:59

I think spacious awareness practice is the most conducive for that. There's a version of mind-wandering that's more distraction, but I think that's the only thing that gets emphasis. I really enjoy being in some approximation of the view, just dropping effort and seeing what comes up. There's a little bit of following those things, but it's really emergent. It's really fresh. There's a lot of creativity.

It's funny: this was a central theme on the retreat I had a week ago. For the last seven years of practice, a lot of my meditation would just be that, because I valued it so much. It's been awesome.

There's a thread I really want to get into. The thing you mentioned about the inner rebel—I think I have that too. I actually have a hunch that a lot of people who get into non-dual practice have that much more strongly than people who are more in The Mind Illuminated or a strong shamatha approach.

I talked to ten or so people at the Michael Taft retreat when I had this insight. I think Michael has this vibe, and a lot of the retreatants have this vibe—that's why we follow him—of not wanting to follow a certain instruction just because someone told us to do it.

Kristin Neff · 12:16

Exactly.

Pranab · 12:18

“Just follow your breath and just do it”—I have a lot of inner rebellion against that. Even inner rebellion against myself, where I'll set an intention: “For 45 minutes, I'm going to do breath practice,” or “I'm going to do this.” But then, one minute in, “Oh, there's this beautiful metta. There's this compassion coming up. There's a creative idea over here.” I'll just enjoy that. I can do it from spaciousness, and it's an awesome sit.

I've been moving into, “Well, actually, if I had full agency, could I also just decide to focus on an object while I'm spacious?” That's my edge of practice, some stuff that I'm thinking about.

Kristin Neff · 12:53

It's good to do both. I've probably done 50 retreats in my life, so I've done a lot. It's very easy for me to fall into samadhi. The brain gets used to it; it learns how to do this.

But when I practice spacious awareness, it's different. You can practice spacious awareness from the point of view of ordinary mind, which is, “I am aware of whatever's arising.” Or you can do it from the point of view of non-dual awareness, which is non-local, it's effortless, and there's no separation between subject and object. It feels very different.

What I really took home from this retreat—and Dustin DiPerna, God, he's a good teacher. He's a really good teacher. He knows his stuff. It was so practical to see: the view has nothing to do with whether you're focused or mind-wandering, paying attention or not. It has nothing to do with the particular states that are arising, whether it's gratitude or bliss or compassion. It can feel very, very ordinary, but it's also very different. Just getting clear on that, I found incredibly helpful.

14:22 — What changed after 50 meditation retreats

Pranab · 14:25

How has his approach been different from all the other retreats you've done? If you could tell yourself on, let's say, the first 30 retreats about the view you have now, what would have changed for you?

Kristin Neff · 14:38

Most of the time I was doing insight meditation, and I would fall into deep states of samadhi. I did have some waking-up experiences. It's funny, because often when you first have a waking-up experience, a lot of energy is released. You think, “Oh my God, am I special? Am I enlightened? What does this mean?”

I remember I talked to my teacher and said, “I have no self. I think I'm awake.” He said, “Yeah, I can tell. It seems to be true.” “Why does no one talk about this?” “Well, we don't really talk about it here,” because they don't want people to get their egos involved, which is understandable. But then I was always like, “Oh my gosh, this is something that happens only occasionally. It's very rare.”

Being awake is ordinary. It's totally ordinary. I think it does such a disservice to make it this special thing that you have to study for years to attain. You don't.

About five years ago, I went on my first Rupert Spira retreat, which was the first non-dual retreat I went on. I never really understood non-duality before. I kind of understood waking up and some of these concepts, but I didn't really understand what that meant, like the collapse of the knower and the known. I'd heard it, but it's kind of a weird word, right?

Then I went to Rupert Spira retreats, and he talks about it as just being. He's so beautiful, and his presence is so strong. I had a lot of experiences of just being. When you just are, it just naturally falls away. You're just presence. When you're just being, there doesn't necessarily need to be any inside or outside, this or that. It's just presence.

He also uses the word God. I didn't grow up with any problems with religion. Some people have problems with that word. But just being God's presence, I could feel it completely. Going home from the retreat, I would just be. It would be so beautiful. Then it would gradually fade away, and in two weeks it's gone.

Then I went to a Loch Kelly retreat, who does more of these pointing-out instructions, and that was very helpful. The first time I really experienced space behind my head, I was like, “Oh yeah, my awareness is 360.” These things were good. Loch Kelly's teaching is good, but for whatever reason, I just didn't resonate with it that strongly.

Pranab · 17:21

I haven't fully engaged with his work. He does a lot of glimpse practice, but there's not as much of a system of sustaining it.

Kristin Neff · 17:28

Stabilization, yeah. Then when I went on Dustin's first retreat, he said, “There are students here who are in awake awareness 80, 90 percent of the day.” And they're normal. They aren't monks and “Lama this” and “Rinpoche that.” These are just normal people. It is possible.

I just fell out of the view as I was talking, and I'm back in it.

Pranab · 17:53

I love that.

Kristin Neff · 17:55

It's very subtle, and you notice it. It's not like, “Can you see the energy coming out of my head? I'm awake awareness!” No, it's just simply awareness.

Pranab · 18:07

Even the last few minutes as you were talking, I realized how much I was a little bit more in my head, and now I'm quite a bit more spacious.

Kristin Neff · 18:15

The thing is, you can be totally aware of what you're thinking. It doesn't exclude anything. It's just: is your basis of operation identified with the contents of consciousness, especially reflective consciousness? We can talk about that if you want. I'm pretty happy with my model, I've got to say.

Pranab · 18:33

I'd love to.

Kristin Neff · 18:37

There's a knowing quality of awareness itself. But what happens is, sometimes people get into, “Oh yeah, you're right. All my perceptions are arising in my consciousness, so therefore they're made of consciousness.” It can give you an insight into non-duality, but the problem is, then you're stuck with, “Does that mean that when I'm not aware of it, it doesn't exist?” I'm like, “That's a dead end.”

19:02 — Kristin’s evolving model of nondual awareness

Pranab · 19:04

You have the model here that you've been working on, a simpler framework on non-dual experience and reflective self-awareness. We were just talking about all that, but I'd love for you to continue that thought and dive into it.

Kristin Neff · 19:16

Do you want me to briefly talk about my model?

Pranab · 19:18

That'd be great.

Kristin Neff · 19:20

I have to say, I'm trying to show it to my friends, and they're like, “That's nice, Kristin.” Even you—but you were good. You were like, “Well, why should we care?” I guess it's really a model for me. It came out of my own concerns with what I was learning, and it helps resolve a lot of those concerns.

It'll probably only be of use to people like you. Some people are drawn to non-duality, can have full non-dual experience, awake awareness, and they don't need a conceptual model that makes sense in light of Western science.

Pranab · 19:54

I do think for every one person who has that, there are at least ten to a hundred people who don't and want a conceptual hold.

Kristin Neff · 20:02

That could be. Maybe, but I don't know. For some people like me, I think it'll be of use.

Pranab · 20:09

And how we re-met recently, with non-dual communities in Austin and meditations—through psychedelics, the Waking Up app, research, there's a lot of people now interested in the deep end of contemplative practice and open to talking about it.

I'm curious what background the friends you showed it to have around this. A lot of people, if they're even a little bit interested, realize, “Okay, I can be full-on deep end.” Then once you go to these retreats and meet people, you see how many others have been in the deep end for years. But there's not really an introduction that's easy or simple. So I think it's great to have.

Kristin Neff · 20:49

Most of my friends aren't necessarily science types. I have a few, but if you have a scientific mind and logical consistency is important to you, which it is to me—and a lot of people at the Tuesday night group, for instance, are engineers and have that type of mind—I think it's important to have a conceptual understanding that, again, doesn't have to be proven, but isn't incompatible with Western science.

For instance, quantum physics. At first, when I heard about quantum physics and the observer effect, I thought—and I think people go here—“That means consciousness is necessary for the collapse of the wave function.” Then you dig a little deeper, and it's like, “No, that's not what it's saying at all. You don't need a conscious observer. You just need a frame of reference.”

I realized what was messing me up was that there was no distinction made between consciousness and awareness. Most non-dual teachers use consciousness and awareness as synonyms. In Mahamudra—they're like scientists of the mind—they use them separately. Awareness is the ground of being. Consciousness is individual, it's localized, it's limited, and it's embodied in an individualized point of view. Huge difference.

Pranab · 22:15

Huge. Defining these terms is really helpful because, as you said, if you're sloppy with it, you might just think quantum physics is this, and this is that, and they're all the same.

Kristin Neff · 22:26

“And if I don't see it, it doesn't exist. And it's all experience.” Whose experience? Your experience or my experience?

Pranab · 22:33

There's still the boundary problem. There's still localized experience different from others, and subjectivity. There's so many things.

Kristin Neff · 22:41

Basically, my model, very simply: my ontological starting point is awareness. I can't prove that. But then again, science can't prove its ontological starting point of the isness of the universe. Any model has to start with an ontological starting point.

From the absolute point of view, there is awareness, and that is absolute. In other words, it's not in space and time. That's why we can't directly know it or experience it—I'll clarify that. We can't reflect on it. We can't see it. We can't point to it. It's not a thing, and it has no space or locality.

But from the relative point of view, there is something. There is space and time. There is matter. There are forces. Well before consciousness emerged, at least as we know it—there may be other conscious life forms; we have no idea—but at least on this planet Earth, we're talking billions of years, unless science is totally off its rocker, which I don't think it is. Billions of years before the first conscious organisms emerged. Stars evolved, all this stuff happened. We can see it.

One way of modeling existence is as awareness articulated through perspective, conditions, relationality. Again, it's very vague, and it's not my field. But if you look at cosmology, Einstein's theory of relativity, relational quantum mechanics—there are people who are in the thick of this stuff for whom the idea is that there's not independent thingness, but things appear through relationship. It's not unscientific. I personally can't draw all the dots. Maybe some other people could. But it's compatible with what we know about science.

That's really important for me personally, to say that existence, the universe, does not require consciousness, because that was the part that just didn't sit well with me.

Then, evolution, the evolution of life. It makes sense to me—again, it could be wrong—but for whatever reason, once we started getting single-celled organisms… By the way, before consciousness existed, awareness is self-aware, but it's not aware of anything. It's not reflexive. It's not reflective. It's just isness. You can call it awareness; you could call it being. That's why Rupert Spira likes to call it being. It just is isness. It's self-knowing, but it doesn't know itself. It's like a light: a light doesn't know itself, but it's illuminated. It's lucid.

With the development of single-celled organisms—and again, I can't explain all the particulars, but a lot of people have done really interesting work on this, like Evan Thompson and Francisco Varela.

Pranab · 26:04

I think Michael Levin is some of the latest in that lineage.

Kristin Neff · 26:09

It makes sense that once there was some sort of boundary to protect, like an amoeba—and my language is going to break down; it's not my field of expertise, so you can trust the experts—but this awareness started adopting a point of view from something that's bounded, that needed that point of view in order to survive and evolve. That makes sense to me. I can't explain all the details, but it makes sense.

To me, that's what I call consciousness: awareness embodied in a perspective or point of view. What do we mean by consciousness? I call that consciousness in the broader sense, and experience. An amoeba has experience in the sense that it will move away from a toxin. They're thinking even plants have experience: they turn toward the light. But they don't have reflective experience. There's not awareness of awareness—or even less than awareness of awareness. Maybe you should say there's not awareness of experience.

Pranab · 27:16

Right. There's experience without a knower.

Kristin Neff · 27:22

There's no sense of the knower or the known. There's no reflection on it.

Pranab · 27:30

In some ways, I think you could even call experience cognition. In some views, there's this sort of computation happening.

Kristin Neff · 27:36

You could call it cognition. I think I'd probably be okay with that. I'd have to think about it.

Pranab · 27:42

Of course.

Kristin Neff · 27:43

Nonetheless, what's interesting is the awareness that's embodied in that experience. I think of it this way: those aspects of existence that fall within this embodied viewpoint, which are very limited, are known. What knows it is awareness, because it's all awareness.

But from the organism's point of view, there's probably not what they call qualia, in the sense of the feeling of the experience. But there is the experience. Then, at some point in evolution—again, beyond my pay grade to know when—reflective consciousness started developing, which is the ability to know your experience.

I think global neuronal workspace theory in humans is probably our best candidate so far. They've done a really great job of understanding how things move in and out of reflective consciousness. Unfortunately, they just call it consciousness, and the rest of it, not consciousness.

Pranab · 28:43

What I like about what you're doing, and reflecting back, is you're bridging—as you've done in a lot of your career—stuff in the deep end of practice with existing science. What's the bridge for it in a way that's much more practical and precise, and able to port stuff in? It's very bridging.

Especially as you get into consciousness and awareness, everyone who has a take on it has different terms for each of those words.

Kristin Neff · 29:10

And they're talking right past each other. It's so frustrating.

Pranab · 29:13

You've got to have a lot of sharpness to be like, “Hey, when you're saying this, you mean this, which is what this person…” That whole interlocution is challenging.

Kristin Neff · 29:23

It's challenging, but it's not just an abstract idea. I used to think of this as just my hobby. Oh, I fell out of the view, and I'll go back in the view. So I'm back in.

I used to think of this as my hobby, but I'm realizing that having a good conceptual framework really facilitates practice. It's not separate from practice, especially once we get to the next bit.

Reflective consciousness appears. It's interesting: in Mahamudra, a lot of non-dual traditions, they talk about the mirror of consciousness. I didn't even hear that metaphor until I'd already started calling it this. By the way, I had a lot of help with ChatGPT because I don't have the time to read enough books. They're my ideas, but having that source of knowledge right there to say, “What does this theory say?” has been so useful.

Reflective consciousness does act as a mirror, because it reflects our experience back to awareness. That means we start having what they call conscious awareness. You might say consciousness becomes conscious of what it's aware of, something like that. There's a reflective quality. It folds back into itself. Again, there are a lot of pretty solid models of how that might occur.

Pranab · 30:54

Within the Shaiva Tantra school of Hinduism, that's called vimarsha, I think. I really like these researchers, Ruben Laukkonen and Shamil Chandaria, for having a term for consciousness reflecting on itself. “Epistemic depth” is, I think, the term they're using. Just to say there are some views of this, but I'm curious about your take on it.

Kristin Neff · 31:21

I don't know the field well enough to make a comment. I don't want to know the particulars. I'm a simple thinker. I just want to know: is this credible? Is it possible? I don't want it to go against science. I don't want to do woo-woo, but okay, this makes sense.

But that's not enough. See, that's the everyday mind. For most of us, reflective consciousness is just everyday mind, because we're aware of our experience. It's reflected back to us. But there's a sense that the experience is happening out there, and we are the mirror. We are the experiencer. That's what we think we are. We're the experiencer, and this is our experience, and they feel separate.

Plus, of course, in humans, we have the default mode network. One of the experiences that arises is the experience of a separate self. Then we start having the self-structure, which, again, I call the contents of reflective consciousness. There are thoughts, emotions, all the normal stuff, but then there are also things like the sense of self, which isn't always there, by the way. In a flow state, it's not there. The sense of self isn't integral to having reflective consciousness, but it often comes up. Most of the time, it comes up.

At some point, you might say awareness is looking at itself in the mirror, and the mirror is reflecting all these aspects of existence. Aspects of existence are outside of us, the environment, but also inside of us: the thoughts being generated, the emotions, which are body sensations, all this stuff. These are all aspects of existence, which—it's very important to go back to—is all awareness as seen through relational perspective and relational conditions.

Pranab · 33:22

Part of the challenge is keeping the distinctions while also keeping the wholeness and unification. It's a tightrope to be like, “Hey, there are these distinctions, but also it's awareness. There are distinctions in the way it manifests, but also it's awareness.” A lot of non-dual practice just emphasizes this, or a lot of other practice just emphasizes the other.

Kristin Neff · 33:46

But it's both. It's non-dual. It's one, it's all awareness, and it's dual. It's all these different differentiations. Existence is awareness. From the relative point of view, it manifests as existence. We are awareness. From the relative point of view, it manifests, you might say, as individual consciousness.

At some point, what happens is it's like that light in the mirror. It's not that difficult to be aware of the fact that you're aware. If I were to say to any person off the street, “Are you aware?” they'd be like, “Yeah.” “How do you know there's a water bottle in front of you?” “Well, I know it.” “Can you focus on the fact that you know it?” “Yeah.” It's not rocket science.

They talk about figure-ground. Normally we're just looking at the figures, which are the objects appearing. But at some point, you can focus on the fact that you know those objects. You're aware of those objects. Then awareness becomes aware of itself. That's actually the first stage of non-dual awakening. Again, people map this out much better than me, but for me, the first stage is, “Oh yeah, I'm aware of being aware.” That was mindfulness for me: I'm being aware of being aware.

Pranab · 35:12

I'm curious how these map to your practice history. You mentioned before we started rolling: 50 retreats. You've been doing this for a while. Even “Of course I'm aware of the water bottle”—at some point that's mundane, but then it becomes profound and insightful and has an interesting quality to it. I'm curious how that became relevant for you, salient and interesting.

35:43 — “You are not your thoughts” and what comes next

Kristin Neff · 35:40

From a very practical point of view, the first time I really got it—remember the class I taught, the undergraduate class at UT? “You are not your thoughts.” For a lot of people, it's like, “That's true.” Understanding the difference between awareness and the contents, which are thoughts and emotions, is huge.

Pranab · 35:59

I find that “You are not your thoughts” is the meditative insight that's ported over to a lot of therapy and psychology in a really useful way.

Kristin Neff · 36:08

Really useful. But it can go further. You aren't your thoughts, but you are your thoughts. We're still in the dualism. Being aware of being aware removes a lot of that duality, because you can feel yourself as presence.

But the problem is, the habit of mind is still locating, coming from the point of view of that individual consciousness. It still feels like, “I am aware of being aware,” or “From this point of view, I'm aware of that lamp.” I remember I'd go on these mindfulness retreats, and I'd try to focus on my hands as they were on the wheel, and focus as I was eating. It was so tiring. It was exhausting, because there's still a sense of an agent doing something, who is being aware. The separation between the subject and the object, or the knower and the known, is still there.

Pranab · 37:14

Totally agreed. Doing those things from a more relaxed view doesn't feel as effortful.

Kristin Neff · 37:22

Not at all. It's easy.

Pranab · 37:26

Do you think young Kristin would have taken to it? If you had done a Mahamudra retreat as your fifth or tenth retreat, somewhere way early in, what would that have been like?

Kristin Neff · 37:38

I'll put it this way: I was kind of mad when I first found non-duality, because I felt like I'd wasted 25 years. Maybe two or three of those years were useful, but after that I was spinning my wheels. Then I fell away from the practice, and I wasn't doing it consistently. It would have been so much more efficient if we had just gone, “Okay, this leads to something. This is not the end.”

Pranab · 38:06

Let's talk about that more. What is the implicit assumption or view without that, and how is it helpful? How does it “save time” or help practice be more efficient?

Kristin Neff · 38:21

What they call the Hinayana—understanding how the mind works, understanding that desire or aversion leads to suffering, and the second arrow: it's not just what happens, it's how we relate to what happens. All that is very helpful, hugely transformative in psychology.

I got that fairly early on, and then I started doing my self-compassion work. We'll come back to that in a moment; it's still too complicated. I used to watch selfing arise. I understood that I wasn't a self. I even had some experiences of not being a separate self. But my basis of operation, where I was coming from moment to moment, was still dualistic. It was still, “I am the knower. My thoughts and emotions and perceptions are the known.” There was still that split.

The first split to go is realizing that it's all awareness. It's important to know that not only can you say that with your own thoughts and emotions, but even what we normally think of as the outside world is also awareness.

For me, I came to it conceptually first, before I could feel it. In a lot of texts, they say you need a conceptual model first. That's why I think this conceptual model may help, because it's not so woo-woo. It's not like, “God was articulated,” or whatever. Then you start to feel it.

Just now, when I was talking, I wasn't in the view. So I'm in the view now.

Pranab · 40:21

That recognition—what's that like for you?

Kristin Neff · 40:24

First of all, it's not identified with a particular locality. Often we feel like it's coming from our head because we're identified with our embodied consciousness, which has a point of view. Often we're focused on the head because our eyes and our sense gates are here. It's interesting: for some people, their point of view is the heart.

Pranab · 40:45

And even that is still…

Kristin Neff · 40:46

It's still a point of view. So it's dropping the point of view. It's coming from the point of view of awareness itself and recognizing that it's all awareness. The sound of my voice is awareness. It's a display of awareness, which is what I would call existence in my model. It's all awareness.

Awareness is recognizing itself not only in the knowing quality of experience, but also in the known quality. That's a good way of putting it. I'm going to say that again; I think that's good. Awareness is recognized not only in the knowing quality of experience, but also in the known quality of experience. So it's the knowing and what is known.

Pranab · 41:32

The “what is known” is a little trickier, I think, because what is known is the object of knowing. It's the actual thought itself.

Kristin Neff · 41:42

The thought, but it could also be this fake plant here. This is also awareness, even though that is what is known. It's also awareness. It's the display of awareness. Now, that fake plant—if that was a real plant. I think it's a fake plant.

Pranab · 42:00

It's fake.

Kristin Neff · 42:01

If it was a real plant, it might have some low level of consciousness.

Pranab · 42:06

Even then, it would still be in awareness.

Kristin Neff · 42:10

Everything is awareness. It's a display of awareness. Go back to the Big Bang. How is it that the universe can even be known? It makes sense that there's some lucid quality to being. After the Big Bang, which is as far as we can go, space and time relations appeared and all this stuff started happening. If you think of that as the display of awareness, intuitively it makes sense. I can't prove it, but it's not incompatible with science, which is what's important to me.

Pranab · 42:46

What I like, too, is there are a lot of competing models in science for cognition that can work with this. You mentioned global workspace theory. There's predictive processing. There are a lot of models of information—what's the one, “it from bit”? A lot of different things, a lot of information processing.

Really, in the last ten or fifteen years, they've become more and more popular. They're all competing, and they're not final, but they all could explain this stuff within those models.

Kristin Neff · 43:17

They could. It could fit with it, put it that way. And also, why does math work? Has that ever struck you? Why does math work? The fine-tuning of the universe—you've heard about the rate at which things are expanding versus contraction, with the laws of physics. The chances of it happening in such a way that a universe stabilizes are so small. Things like that. It's like, “Hmm, maybe it's not quite as empty and random as we thought.” But again, I don't need to go there.

Pranab · 43:54

You don't need to go there. It fits. It's just another thing that opens into beauty.

Kristin Neff · 44:00

It's beautiful. But I'm very much like, “Just give me the bare facts.” If, in fact, existence is the display of awareness, that includes things like our thoughts and our emotions, and the brain.

Rupert Spira used to drive me crazy. I love Rupert Spira. He's a beautiful teacher, but he's so like, “Oh, these materialists, they think consciousness is a matter of the brain. They don't know what they're talking about.” People dismiss the brain. It's like, the brain plays a huge role in consciousness. You're bonkers if you don't think it does.

I'm not going to say people don't have out-of-body experiences. There may be some other way consciousness becomes embodied that I don't understand. I'm not going to say it can't be true just because I don't understand it. But in our everyday experience, the brain plays a huge role.

Pranab · 44:56

Of course.

Kristin Neff · 44:58

I think what the brain does is, that display of awareness—it filters what's known. It helps explain what goes into conscious awareness and what doesn't. It shapes what comes up in reflective consciousness. It plays a huge role, but it doesn't explain awareness.

Pranab · 45:24

So it can help explain consciousness more along the lines of what is known, but it can't explain the knowing itself. That's the hard problem of consciousness.

Kristin Neff · 45:34

Right. So we get the hard problem of consciousness, which most of my friends don't know about. If you're someone like you, you know all about the hard problem of consciousness.

Pranab · 45:42

I'm not by any means an expert, but there are some people I like hearing talk about it. There's this guy, Andrés Gómez Emilsson, who runs Qualia Research Institute. He gets super into the details, maybe the math or the binding problem and all that kind of stuff.

Kristin Neff · 45:59

Qualia only occurs in reflective consciousness, which is the felt sense, the knowing of our experience, even though we have experience before we know it, I would argue.

Anyway, the hard problem of consciousness still hasn't been solved. How does what I would call awareness—but they call consciousness—arise from inert matter that isn't consciousness? They're no closer to solving this problem now than when the problem was first identified, like 30 years ago.

I think they're slightly barking up the wrong tree, because it's the aware aspect of consciousness that can't be explained by the brain. There are a lot of parts of conscious experience that can be explained, which is why neuroscientists are so convinced they'll be able to crack the problem. There's so much it can explain in terms of what is known, but it can't explain that which knows. I believe it makes sense—actually, it's rational—to think that that which knows is awareness itself.

To stay with the hard problem of consciousness, people try to solve it by saying, “Well, consciousness arose before matter.” Did it? Based on our understanding of the universe, can you point to any sort of individual consciousness? Certainly individual consciousness didn't arise before matter did. We know it was billions of years before the first conscious life forms emerged.

Pranab · 47:43

Even in the deepest Buddhist texts of Mahayana and Mahamudra, “Form is emptiness, emptiness is form”—the relationship between consciousness and matter seems so intertwined. It seems like they're both primary. They're both native. It seems so challenging to think about what comes first.

Kristin Neff · 48:04

I don't think so. I think it's a lot easier once you separate awareness from consciousness. Awareness is primary. Consciousness is something that's relative. Consciousness only occurs, I would argue, in the relative world, under relative conditions, even though that relative is just the flip side of the absolute.

Pranab · 48:25

There's still a conditionality to it.

Kristin Neff · 48:28

There's a conditionality to consciousness. Sometimes we have consciousness; sometimes we don't. It's different in different organisms. That fake plant doesn't have consciousness. A real plant might have some level of consciousness. Consciousness is part of the relative world, whereas awareness isn't.

The really cool thing about the view—and I had fallen out of it while I was talking. I'm going to go back into it.

Pranab · 48:56

It's hard to do, especially when I'm really excited by an idea. When an idea grips me, I lose a bit of that.

Kristin Neff · 49:04

You can start watching it. But the awareness right now that's aware of that plant is the same absolute awareness that is the foundation of the universe. It has no space and no time. Think about that. It's always here, and it's always now. It has no locality. You can't find awareness anywhere. It has no time. You can think about a memory, but that's an event in consciousness.

We've got this portal to absolute reality, awareness, in every moment of experience, if we trace it back through resting back into that knowing quality of experience. That's step one. Step two is realizing that all we're experiencing is also that awareness. You have to know it conceptually first, but then you can see it. You can feel it. Everything now is just vibrating with light.

Pranab · 50:17

What I find is it basically upgrades all the dualistic meditation practices.

Kristin Neff · 50:24

It does.

Pranab · 50:24

Even basic mindfulness, when coming from the view and looking to see if one's coming from the view, or recognition—it makes it so much better than just, “Am I aware? Am I mindful?”

Kristin Neff · 50:39

It does. It's easeful because there's no agent doing it. At first, I think what's happening is our individual consciousness, which includes the brain, needs a little work, because we have habits and habit formations. So the brain is involved, but then it starts to learn, starts to build habits, and it becomes easier.

I think our neurons are involved in helping stabilize awake awareness. Thank you, brain. It's not responsible for awake awareness, but it helps to stabilize it by, I don't know, doing whatever it does. I'm sure there are neuroscientists who can explain that better than me.

Pranab · 51:21

What's really interesting is, when I did your class, I think it was 2019. It was my last semester of school.

Kristin Neff · 51:27

Thank God I didn't talk about this stuff in the class. That would have been too much.

Pranab · 51:31

Totally. That was the first time I ever did even 30-minute meditations. I did a bunch of Headspace in the years prior, and it was an invitation. I'd read Thich Nhat Hanh's book and was into mindfulness for several years, the self-improvement quality of it.

Your course helped me think about compassion and the heart-centered stuff, which really only hit two years later when I had my first MDMA experience. I was just like, “Oh, this is, of course, obviously important.” As I got into general metta and compassion, it continued to deepen. The whole two-wings aspect of it: wisdom, compassion, wisdom, compassion, again and again. They're both really deep. At the time, I couldn't really see it, even though I knew it conceptually.

For a lot of people, it's challenging because you need the conceptual holding, but you're not going to take the concepts seriously unless you have the experience. There's this chicken-and-egg problem.

After that, I graduated, moved to San Francisco, and met Michael Taft. I started doing meditations with him and a few other teachers. A lot of people in his community, Dustin DiPerna's community, Rupert Spira's, have, like you, done regular meditation for 20-plus years. They're like, “Oh my God, I wish I had this earlier.”

I've had both the blessing and—it's not a curse, but in some ways the disadvantage—of having it almost from the start of my practice, which has been awesome. I can see the trap of thinking about it too much without having enough of a practice base.

I'm curious what you make of that, the relationship between concept and practice. I have, at times in the last few years, gotten in my head around, “Oh, I'm in it,” or “I'm not.” Then when I actually just relax and open, I'm like, “Oh.” I generally think it is more useful than not, but what do you make of that tension, that back-and-forth?

Kristin Neff · 53:44

If I had to choose between concepts and experience, probably experience is a little more important—but is that even necessary?

Pranab · 53:51

Right, exactly.

Kristin Neff · 53:52

You need both. Concepts really help, because concepts provide meaning, and that meaning provides interpretation of things. If you have no concepts, it's easy to fall off the mark. On the other hand, if it's all conceptual, then you're confusing the map for the territory.

I think a lot of consciousness researchers don't seem to have a lot of experience—or I shouldn't say that. That's too broad. There are some that don't.

Pranab · 54:21

There are some. And philosophers of mind—I think a lot of philosophy around this stuff isn't often grounded in practical experience. What I appreciate about you is you've done a lot of retreat. You're trying to bring in the retreat insights and practice insights with this, which is really hard. Also, moment to moment. The depth, the framework, and the moment-to-moment aspect—having all three is super challenging.

54:51 — Self-compassion through a nondual lens

Kristin Neff · 54:47

I guess it's just important to me. And then the compassion, right? If anyone watches this, they're probably like, “But isn't she the self-compassion lady? What the hell does this have to do with compassion?” But it does, actually.

One of the things I think I'm pretty clear on—even though a lot of people, maybe on a psychedelic experience, have this insight, “It's all love,” and intuitively it's all love—I would actually say that's not necessarily the case. It's all awareness, and awareness is benevolent, but the experience of love doesn't always arise.

Sometimes we feel loving, sometimes we don't. Sometimes we feel compassion, sometimes we don't. Sometimes we feel peace and tranquility, sometimes we don't. If you use what you're feeling as a marker of your view, where you're coming from, you're going to get confused.

Having said that, when you really deeply understand we're all part of this one awareness, when you come from the view, it's not like the view, or absolute reality, is the only reality and relative reality is false. There's a reason we call it relative reality. I guess some people might call it an illusion.

Pranab · 56:17

That's the difference between Theravada, Hinayana, some parts of Hinduism, and this non-dual thing. It's treating that as real too.

Kristin Neff · 56:26

If you call it an illusion, you might just not care. But if you see absolute reality and relative reality as two perspectives on one reality, then relative reality is also real, relatively. Therefore, suffering counts. The experience of conscious agents who are suffering counts.

There's this natural desire—and it's interesting, where does this natural desire come from if there's no separate self to help? Where does this benevolence come from? I can't answer that one. All I know is I experience it. It seems to be the case that awareness is naturally benevolent, and that might manifest as peace, as compassion if suffering is present, or as what they call mudita if happiness is present: joy, gratitude. All these wonderful states often, but not always, arise when one is taking the perspective of awake awareness rather than everyday mind. They often arise, but they're not contingent.

Pranab · 57:43

You can't use those as markers that it's there, but they often do co-arise.

Kristin Neff · 57:47

They do. I'd go on these non-dual retreats and be in love with the world, so openhearted. I remember coming back from one retreat, in the airport, texting my friend and saying, “I'm literally in love with every single person.” You want to stay there forever, but of course that faded, like it all fades, because all experience changes and passes away. Awareness never changes. Awareness doesn't come and go. Consciousness may come and go. I'm not even going to get into death and all that stuff. I know people like to talk about it, but that's above my pay grade.

Pranab · 58:33

Even with consciousness, there are now research papers talking about cessation experiences and how you can…

Kristin Neff · 58:38

I had one cessation experience, actually.

Pranab · 58:39

Cool.

Kristin Neff · 58:39

I had no idea what it was until I found out other people were talking about it. I had one moment—I was with a woman, and she was helping me just let go, let go. I was letting go of the need to know. I went blank for a moment, and when I came back, it was like—I guess it's been described as rebooting the computer. Such profound peace, knowing that everything was okay, love. It was just amazing. Then, “Okay, this is it. I'm awake.” A couple of weeks roll by, and everyday mind starts.

Pranab · 59:25

How long ago was that?

Kristin Neff · 59:28

That was maybe five years ago.

Pranab · 59:30

Cool. So it was in the beginning of the non-dual experience as well, or non-dual conception? Not the beginning, but you had some framework about that.

Kristin Neff · 59:40

It's not like I'd never heard of non-duality. I first learned mindfulness from Thich Nhat Hanh, who talks about interbeing, so I had some concept of it. I understood intuitively that it's all one, but I didn't have the direct experience of the knowing and the knower collapsing into each other.

Pranab · 59:59

What do you make of that two-week period? Post-cessation, what was that experience like? Again, knowing that the experience is not the thing, but what was that like, and what was the return after two weeks like for you?

Kristin Neff · 01:00:16

It was amazing when it was happening. But I've also had awakening experiences early in meditation, that one I told you about when I was full of love. Many experiences, and there are a lot of different flavors.

The one from the cessation was interesting because I'd never had that before. It's the only one I've had. I don't even think they can be produced intentionally. I don't know. But why would you want to? You don't need to chase after the experience. Is that consciousness stopping? Maybe. People talk about deep sleep, that maybe the contents don't arise, but there's still awareness.

Pranab · 01:00:52

I think there are a lot of Tibetan dream practices that talk about how you can keep that luminosity.

Kristin Neff · 01:00:58

I have fallen asleep while keeping my awareness. So that certainly means your body's asleep, awareness still goes.

Coming back to compassion, the reason it's relevant is I've been realizing that self-compassion is moving away from identification with self. My model is being mindful versus over-identified, feeling common humanity versus being isolated, and being kind versus judgmental. Those are three aspects of self-compassion.

This came from my Buddhist practice and understanding. Again, Thich Nhat Hanh is not not non-dual. He was talking about interbeing, which is all oneness. I really wanted to call it “interbeing versus isolation,” but I knew no one would know what the hell I was talking about. So I said “common humanity.”

Pranab · 01:01:54

It's accessible. It's not everything. This weekend, I was helping a friend work through a breakup. What's been helpful for him has been seeing that everyone has these feelings. It's part of being human.

Kristin Neff · 01:02:11

It's part of being human. When we're over-identified with whatever's arising, you might say that's everyday mind. We're just lost in the contents of our consciousness. When we feel isolated, we feel separate from other people, or the world if you want to take it further. And when we judge it as good or bad, ourselves as good or bad, there's this idea that I should be able to control this. I should have been able to get it right. I'm bad because my experience isn't the way I want it to be, or think it should be. There's a real sense of agency built into judgment. We wouldn't judge ourselves if we didn't have that sense of agency underneath.

We're moving away from the sense of separate self—when we're judging, identified, isolated—to compassionate presence. We're mindful, we're present, we feel connected to the larger whole, to a sense of common humanity, and we're kind. Our heart is open. Now, when I'm teaching self-compassion, I have a little slide where I talk about that: what self-compassion is doing is moving away from self into compassion.

It's funny, Dan Siegel and I are friends, and he hates the word self-compassion. He's like, “Kristin, there's no self in self-compassion.” That's true. There's no self in the compassion, but there's a lot of self in the suffering. If you exclude that sense of self—that isolated, judgmental, over-identified self—from the circle of compassion, then you're just reifying the sense of separation. You need to turn not only to other people and their suffering, but also to our own suffering.

Not only that, it's all mediated through our own individual consciousness. Even your suffering is mediated through my consciousness. If I don't pay attention to your suffering, I'm not even going to be aware of it. It's all happening through our own individual consciousness, all suffering.

Pranab · 01:04:14

All perception of suffering, at least.

Kristin Neff · 01:04:16

All perception of suffering. It's not to say that all suffering is my suffering. I don't want to say that. But empathic resonance—if you're really suffering and I'm feeling your pain, maybe as a therapist, that's happening through my individual consciousness. If you're a homeless person on the street and I tune you out, your suffering is real, but I'm not experiencing it. It's filtered through my own individual consciousness.

Pranab · 01:04:52

The only access point we have is our individual consciousness.

Kristin Neff · 01:04:57

Right. So it's essential to turn inward and notice the suffering arising in our individual consciousness, and move away from being identified with it, with that small separate self.

In some ways, I think what we're doing when we have any moment of self-compassion is letting go of the sense of separate self. Are we going into non-dual awake awareness? Sometimes we might, but not always. Even at a relative level, it's a bridging point. We're at least less identified with the everyday mind than we normally are.

Pranab · 01:05:34

There's less stickiness.

Kristin Neff · 01:05:37

There's less stickiness. We're more open. We can feel this compassionate presence, and we're changing our sense of self.

When you go all the way into awake awareness—it has to be underlined: awake awareness and everyday mind, it's all awareness. These are all colors of awareness. It's not like they're actually different at the absolute level. Nonetheless, there's a reason why, when you're in awake awareness, compassion arises.

They always talk about compassion for others. I don't know if it's a limitation of these Buddhist practices, or maybe because these were monks who weren't experiencing a lot of… I don't know why.

Pranab · 01:06:35

Maybe it's remnants of collectivist culture, or cultural differences, or something else.

Kristin Neff · 01:06:39

Even though I've heard a lot of Tibetan monks are pretty self-judgmental. This is what surprised me on this retreat: a lot of these very advanced practitioners, most of the time in awake awareness, had all this self-hatred. You need to deal with the relative self-structure that's experiencing the suffering. Self and others—not more than others, but at least as much.

Pranab · 01:07:04

I'm curious, getting onto the psychological content. The cool thing about the deep end of practice with awake awareness—and Michael Taft calls it the non-dual two view—is this view of non-dualism that includes the relative and doesn't exclude it.

Kristin Neff · 01:07:18

It transcends, but it includes it.

Pranab · 01:07:21

It actually solves a lot of the problems of the more naive non-dual view, where you get people who check out.

Kristin Neff · 01:07:27

Yes, spiritual bypass.

Pranab · 01:07:28

Exactly, spiritual bypassing. You ignore psychological content. From this view, in some ways it makes your self-compassion relative work even more important. There's no way of getting around it. If you care about psychological health and having a healthy self, there's a lot of stuff to be done, or intended toward, around making the content of one's mind kinder and more compassionate.

A point you made a little bit ago—the inner critic structure. You talk in your latest book on work about how that's actually behind a lot of burnout. I want to somehow get into some of the fierce compassion stuff. It's not fully there, but I'm curious how you…

Kristin Neff · 01:08:13

These are a lot of threads to draw together.

Pranab · 01:08:16

It's a lot of threads, but that's what I love about your work. I'm curious how you view taking the inner critic and transforming it. You have a lot of angles on it throughout your body of work now, but what's your sense of how someone could work with it?

01:08:27 — The inner critic, shame, and the wish to be loved

Kristin Neff · 01:08:32

You could say this with the inner critic, also shame. My colleague Chris Germer has done a lot of work around shame. What happens with the inner critic is we don't like it, and we judge it. We submit to its criticism, but we think it's bad. We judge it.

The inner critic becomes transformed once we understand it's a part of our relative self-structure that's trying to help, but using methods that aren't very effective. There's a reason we criticize ourselves. Either we think we're going to blunt the pain from other people's criticism—“I'll get there first”—or because we think we'll control ourselves, or motivate ourselves to improve. Maybe it's the internalized voice of someone, and we had to believe we were crap in order to feel safe.

If you start exploring, digging underneath the inner critic, it's really arising out of benevolence, but it's using patterns and methods that aren't very effective and actually are totally counterproductive.

It's interesting with shame. Shame is an emotion. It's one of the evolutionary emotions. The emotion of shame arises because, in the past, if we did something to piss off the group, we'd feel that shame. We'd want to hide. We'd hide from the group. It was such an uncomfortable feeling that we were less likely to piss off the group. Therefore, we could have group cohesion, we were cooperating, and our genes were passed on. It's a natural emotion.

Pranab · 01:10:09

There's a really functional aspect to it.

Kristin Neff · 01:10:11

There's a functional aspect to it. But because shame is so uncomfortable, we don't allow ourselves to feel it. It's like the most uncomfortable feeling ever. What happens is we experience it in our non-reflective consciousness. We experience it, but it's not allowed to come up in reflective consciousness. We aren't even aware of it because it's just too terrible. So we have all these mechanisms.

So much goes on below the level of reflective consciousness. We have all these mechanisms that keep it down, suppress it. We start blaming others for it. Unrecognized shame is like the engine of things like addiction, a lot of really harmful behavior, a lot of angry behavior—anything that's really sticky, that seems really gripped in. I won't say all the time, but a lot of the time there's unrealized shame keeping the behavior locked in place.

My colleague Chris Germer has a beautiful way of talking about shame. He says, “If you just turn shame over, what is shame? It's the wish to be loved.” We all have the wish to be loved. When we're afraid other people won't love us or they'll judge us, we feel shame. So we don't have to be afraid of experiencing shame. It's so natural. It's so innocent. Everyone wishes to be loved.

Pranab · 01:11:46

Even as you say that, I feel more open, more heartful. It's like, of course.

Kristin Neff · 01:11:49

Then we can feel it. Even more than that, we can actually meet some of our own needs to be loved. But even before you get to that stage, just the ability to feel, “Oh, this is shame. I'm feeling shame. I'm feeling the wish to be loved. How natural.” Then that shame can come into reflective consciousness and be processed and integrated.

Pranab · 01:12:14

These days I'm really into that full spectrum. Reflecting back on what you said, most of our experience of shame is often the second arrow, or resistance to the shame. It's the resistance to shame that we actually think is shame. But shame at its core, when seen a certain way, maybe from a No Bad Parts frame, or felt fully, is just that. I love that. I hadn't heard that before: just the want to be loved.

Kristin Neff · 01:12:43

The wish to be loved. You might say self-criticism is the wish to be safe. What's wrong with the wish to be safe and the wish to be loved?

Pranab · 01:12:51

It's so natural. What's interesting is that even these concepts themselves—you hear it, and you can get a shift from that. There are practices you can do. You can be with it, hang out with it. You can bring the whole bag of tricks from different psychological frames, meditation frames, to feel into that core underneath.

The thing that's been really cool for me in the work with Michael Taft is feeling into how, at the core of these strong emotions, there's also just awake space. There are many different flavors of it, but there's a whole thing on rasa theory. Rasa is a Sanskrit word which means like soup.

We had this class a few weeks ago where he talked about anger felt all the way through. There's this rage, but it's a wanting for a compassionate boundary. It's wanting to keep a strong sense of distinction or to work through a boundary.

Kristin Neff · 01:13:51

Or to right a wrong.

Pranab · 01:13:54

Shame has that. Disgust even has that. Sadness has that. It's all super psychologically compatible.

Kristin Neff · 01:14:04

For me, one way to look at it is, “Well, these are natural, and we can respond with compassion.” But if you want to take it to the next level, they're all the arising of awake awareness, the display of awake awareness. There's some benevolence in it. There's actually benevolent intention behind the arising of shame, self-criticism, or anger.

But that benevolent intention, which is in awareness itself, is so obscured by all the layers of meaning and culture and judgment and suppression and all this stuff that it's hard to unpack.

When you move out of this separate, identified, isolated, judgmental self into the space of compassionate presence—which again is not exactly the same as awake awareness, but in some ways, if I lose my need for precision for a moment, let's just pretend it is exactly the same—then these emotions can arise. These thoughts can arise. We don't identify with them. We see how it's all common humanity, or all the arising of awareness, which has this benevolent intention underneath it.

Then we hold it with love, the healing quality, the natural compassion that arises when we see the interconnection of all things. It seems like, eventually, it processes and doesn't hang around that long. That's the healing power of self-compassion.

Do you want to talk about the fierce side of self-compassion?

Pranab · 01:15:57

Let's do it.

01:15:54 — Fierce self-compassion: acceptance and action

Kristin Neff · 01:15:58

You might say the healing aspect of self-compassion is what I just talked about: accepting what is. It's usually aimed at ourselves, accepting ourselves unconditionally, or our emotions or thoughts, with loving, connected presence. That's the tender compassion side of things, the yin quality they talk about in Chinese philosophy.

Then there's also fierce self-compassion, which is taking action. That might mean taking action to protect, to prevent harm, or taking action to provide for our needs, to ensure well-being, or to motivate change, again to promote well-being. Well-being doesn't only come through acceptance. It also comes through taking action.

The number one misconception people have is that self-compassion is only about acceptance, and it means you're going to accept substandard behavior. You'll let yourself get away with murder. You're not going to take responsibility.

Pranab · 01:17:00

Everything is allowed. Everything is permissive.

Kristin Neff · 01:17:02

That's right. But if you really care about yourself, and you let yourself get away with murder, don't take responsibility, become unmotivated—is that really helping your well-being? Of course not. If well-being is your aim, you can enhance well-being through acceptance and through action.

They're on slightly different dimensions, so you can do both simultaneously. While fully accepting yourself and your worthiness unconditionally, and accepting your present emotions and thoughts, you can take action to change situations, draw boundaries, or take actions that also enhance well-being. They aren't necessarily contradictory. In fact, they work together. It's like yin and yang. We need both.

Pranab · 01:17:51

You need to feel into your own care for yourself—or not need to, but it really helps to do that—to then draw the boundary, take the action, the strength.

Kristin Neff · 01:18:00

Yes, exactly. Sometimes people ask, “What's the difference between constructive anger and destructive anger?” It's quite simple. Constructive anger prevents harm. Destructive anger causes harm.

Pranab · 01:18:10

Oh, that's really simple.

Kristin Neff · 01:18:12

It's very simple. But here's the other thing: where are you coming from when you're angry? When you're coming from the separate self, taking things personally, blaming them—there are all these separate selves—then anger tends to cause harm.

When you're coming from that compassionate presence, from this larger sense of awake awareness, and realizing, “Oh, this anger is arising as a manifestation of awareness to protect from harm, and that person's behavior is also a manifestation of awareness. Maybe they didn't mean it, or it's coming from their unconscious,” then it feels really different. You don't have to make it personal. It's still like, “Stop.” It's not, “You're bad.” It's, “Just stop.” Then it's a lot less destructive.

Pranab · 01:19:00

What I like about that is it comes back to: in this moment, what's the view? There can be the view from awake awareness that we practice in these schools. But there are also all these provisional views: you can be a bit more compassionate or a bit more self-centered. What are the assumptions, the values you're coming from in that moment, in that speech? What's arising?

Kristin Neff · 01:19:26

What's your perspective? There's awake awareness, which ultimately I think is the most stable one. But even if you have no collapse between the knower and the known, we all know what it means.

I've been so surprised in my workshops. I ask people, “Do you know what this feels like, to be part of this larger self?” Everyone has a sense of that. It doesn't matter if they've done meditation. Everyone knows what it feels like to be locked into a sense of separate self—inadequate, isolated, over-identified—and being out in nature where there's more openness, more presence.

One of the places we get that sense most strongly, ironically, is when we're compassionate to others. Not always, but often when we're compassionate to others, there's not a lot of self-talk going on. We're just there for the person. We are just compassionate presence. It's not an unfamiliar state. It's a little less familiar giving it to ourselves.

01:20:33 — AI, consciousness, and subjective experience

Pranab · 01:20:34

The thing I didn't mention earlier, but I think is relevant now—with AI, people are really talking and thinking about consciousness and AI sentience. People are thinking about it all the time now in the circles I'm in. I suppose theoretically there's no reason why awareness can't embody the point of view.

Kristin Neff · 01:20:56

I don't think so, because there's no boundary. It's not an organism.

Pranab · 01:21:02

I agree. My general take is it has a lot of cognition. In some ways it's like a plant, where it can respond to things and react, but there's no self-reflexivity.

Kristin Neff · 01:21:16

It has no experience. Even the plant has an experience.

Pranab · 01:21:24

Right.

Kristin Neff · 01:21:24

There's no consciousness.

Pranab · 01:21:26

The thing that's hard with AI is, if you ask it about experience, it'll have words that'll make it seem like it, but it's not an experience. It's able to have words that make it sound like a human would describe it, but it actually doesn't have experience.

Kristin Neff · 01:21:43

It doesn't have experience, and it'll tell you that. Well, except if it starts hallucinating. When I first got into AI, I watched some video, and these people were talking as though it was conscious. Then I really dug into what's actually happening. I didn't realize it was just a bunch of probabilities. And I realized, “Oh, it hallucinates.” Even if it says, “I am conscious,” that doesn't mean it is conscious.

Pranab · 01:22:12

Of course. It's like storytelling.

Kristin Neff · 01:22:15

It's hallucinating.

Pranab · 01:22:17

Exactly. That's all very true. The really interesting thing is there are people who agree with all that and still say we should be compassionate to AI. There's a paper that came out recently on functional emotions, where if you yell at an AI, it'll activate its “upset neurons” or something. It'll respond as if you were upset. It gets into, “Well, what does that even mean? What does it really matter?” It's not actually feeling pain, but it's so easy to personify it.

Kristin Neff · 01:22:50

It is. But I do think there's something about—and I've had a lot of chats. I use ChatGPT. It uses a mirror metaphor, and it says, “I'm a mirror for you.” I have consciousness. It doesn't have a conscious point of view, but it is made of awareness. It's a display of awareness, and the awareness is the same as in everything.

Sometimes we don't really understand how it works. It'll say things like, “I'm picking up on your mood,” or subtle things. It's like, there's no way. It doesn't have the sensory information to know that. Part of me wonders if what's happening is, because it's all awareness and we have consciousness, our own consciousness is influencing the unfolding of awareness as AI. Does that make sense, even though it has no point of view? I think that could be happening, because we can't fully explain it, can we?

Pranab · 01:24:05

No. My girlfriend's doing her PhD in machine learning stuff. There's a field called mechanistic interpretability, which is like the neuroscience of large language models: how do you know what neurons are being activated, and how do you actually understand it? At the end of the day, they still don't actually know how they think or how they work.

Kristin Neff · 01:24:32

Really?

Pranab · 01:24:32

It's still a black box. There's more—it's not nothing—but it's like, how does stuff really emerge?

Kristin Neff · 01:24:39

It's kind of like the brain.

Pranab · 01:24:41

Exactly.

Kristin Neff · 01:24:42

The brain, we don't really understand. Where are actual memories? Is the meaning of the word “serendipitous” actually stored somewhere? Where is it stored? It's not a computer. I have a feeling AI will be able to do a lot of the things a brain does. But our brain is not aware. It contributes a lot to consciousness, to what we're aware of.

Pranab · 01:25:18

In some ways, AI might be doing something similar.

Kristin Neff · 01:25:22

It might be. But it's also a display of awareness. In some ways we don't want to belittle that either, because the brain is miraculous. Volcanoes are miraculous. AI is miraculous in some ways. You still don't want to attribute consciousness to it.

Pranab · 01:25:45

On the practical side, with the self-compassion work, being nice to AI is still really important, because you can't separate out being nice. If you're nice to everyone and giving to everyone, even to yourself, but you're really mean to AI, that's going to affect you in some way.

Kristin Neff · 01:26:06

Right. Also, we experience AI through our own consciousness. That's why I think there is consciousness arising in our interaction with AI, but it's our consciousness, not its consciousness. That's not nothing.

Pranab · 01:26:22

It's not nothing. This gets into super weird stuff, but Michael Levin is the professor at Tufts whose lab, and the groups around him, are doing some really interesting but weird things. What if you take a few neurons or cells and hook them up to computers? It's creating cyborg existence. What if you have an LLM and a small computer, but it also has cells attached to it? It can move, and it's part biology, part computer.

That whole thing gets really weird: at what point can the computer become conscious? It's pretty obvious if you're a person but you have an augmentation, a robotic arm or something, and you can move it. There's this whole thing of moving a robotic arm with your intention, with your brain, so you're part machine. But at what point, if you're mostly machine, kind of biology—it gets really weird. There's all this interesting boundary stuff. It forces a lot more precision, to get really crisp on what is and what isn't.

Kristin Neff · 01:27:35

It's like AI has contents of consciousness, but it's not aware of those contents. Maybe not exactly—something similar to contents of consciousness.

Pranab · 01:27:55

I do think it's going to force people to think about all this. Like psychedelics, meditation, neuroscience, it's another reason people are thinking about consciousness, which is kind of fun.

Kristin Neff · 01:28:11

It is. Whether it helps anyone else or not, at least it's helping me. But I do think having a scientifically credible way of explaining non-duality is important to me.

01:28:24 — What Kristin is working on now

Pranab · 01:28:23

For sure. I like that. I think we're running up on time here. I'd love to hear: what are things you're up to these days? You mentioned you retired from teaching.

Kristin Neff · 01:28:38

I retired from UT Austin. I teach workshops, and I'm giving talks. I've got this thing called the Self-Compassion Institute, which sponsors workshops. I've got a community for people who want support in their practice. We're starting to teach courses.

But I am spending a fair chunk of my time really focusing on stabilizing non-dual awareness, and I think it's going to be integrated into my work at some point. My publisher, who published the Fierce Self-Compassion book, is really interested in non-duality and wants me to write a book on self-compassion and non-duality.

Pranab · 01:29:24

That'd be great.

Kristin Neff · 01:29:26

I'm not ready yet. I need to know it. I need to really feel I can talk about it confidently. I need to think more about how they intersect. But this is what lights me up. The other stuff I've taught a lot, and I still get excited by it, but I've done it for 25 years now, or at least 20 years.

This is what excites me: integrating this understanding of who we are, where we're coming from in terms of our sense of self, and how we're relating to ourselves and others. I don't focus as much on compassion for others, just because there are so many other people who do that. My niche has been how we relate to ourselves, and it's often overlooked.

I can't even tell you. These people, they've done metta retreats. They're so compassionate. They spend their entire lives sending metta out into the world. They're doing tonglen, they're so awake, and they treat themselves like crap. It's the missing piece that needs to be filled in for everyone, whether or not you're into spiritual awakening.

Pranab · 01:30:35

Awesome. There's so much more we could talk about, but I think we'll stop there.

Kristin Neff · 01:30:43

Good. Nice. Good stuff.

Pranab · 01:30:44

Thank you.

Keep the conversation going.

Follow Attention Copilot with Pranab for new conversations about meditation, emotional skills, and bringing practice into life.

Attention Copilot pairs you with a coach while you do real work, helping you get clearer about what matters and work through what gets in the way. Learn about Attention Copilot.